In this article, we’ll be comparing two prop firms, SurgeTrader and Traders With Edge.
Let’s look at all details.
Prop Firms General Details
In this first table, we compare the year where each prop firm was founded, where their offices are located, and how much balance you can get to trade after scaling (when applicable).
|Prop Firm Details||SurgeTrader||Traders With Edge|
|Offices Location||Naples, Florida, USA||USA|
|Keep First Profits|
Here’s a list of all instruments supported by SurgeTrader and Traders With Edge. I divided the list into two parts to show CFDs products and Futures products.
|Instruments CFDs||SurgeTrader||Traders With Edge|
|Instruments Futures||SurgeTrader||Traders With Edge|
|Foreign Exchange Futures|
|Interest Rate Futures|
Funding Program Types
Prop firms have different program types to achieve a funded account.
Here’s the resume and comparison of the SurgeTrader and Traders With Edge different program types.
|Prop Firm Programs||SurgeTrader||Traders With Edge|
|Two Step Evaluation|
Instant Funding Comparison
Instant funding programs give you access to a funded account immediately without needing to pass any challenge.
|Instant Funding Rules||SurgeTrader||Traders With Edge||Traders With Edge|
|Program Name||N/A||Instant Standard||Instant Aggressive|
|Max Daily Loss|
|Max Daily Drawdown|
|Minimum Trading Days||5||5|
|Maximum Trading Days||180||180|
One-Step Program Comparison
One-Step programs are programs that require a single challenge to be passed. As soon as you pass the challenge, achieving the required targets without breaking any rules, you’ll be rewarded with a funded account to trade.
Here’s the comparison table for the SurgeTrader and Traders With Edge prop firms.
|One Step Rules||SurgeTrader||Traders With Edge||Traders With Edge|
|Program Name||Audition||Turtle Standard||Turtle Aggressive|
|Max Daily Loss||4%|
|Max Daily Drawdown||2.5%||5%|
|Minimum Trading Days||10||10|
|Maximum Trading Days||365||365|
|Profit Split||75%, up to 90%||80%||80%|
Two-Step Program Comparison
Two-Step programs require that you pass two different challenges before getting funded. Usually, each phase or each challenge has different targets and rules.
Here’s the comparison for SurgeTrader and Traders With Edge.
|Two Step Rules||SurgeTrader||Traders With Edge||Traders With Edge|
|Program Name||N/A||Hare Standard||Hare Aggressive|
|Profit Target Step 1||10%||20%|
|Profit Target Step 2||5%||10%|
|Max Daily Loss|
|Max Daily Drawdown||10%||20%|
|Min Trading Days Step 1||5||5|
|Min Trading Days Step 2||5||5|
|Max Trading Days Step 1||60||60|
|Max Trading Days Step 2||60||60|
Trustpilot is a reputable platform when it comes to reviewing products and services.
Here is the rating that SurgeTrader and Traders With Edge have on Trustpilot.
|Trustpilot Stats||SurgeTrader||Traders With Edge|
|Number of Reviews||266||150|
Being able to test a prop firm before we commit and purchase is a good thing. We can get used to their trading platform, and understand spreads, commissions, and rules.
Some proprietary firms also offer free repeats in some circumstances, and also free resets, to be able to reset our account before the challenge period is over, in case things are not going as we wanted.
Here’s the comparison for SurgeTrader and Traders With Edge prop firms.
|Free Stuff||SurgeTrader||Traders With Edge|
Some prop firms may be better for you than others depending on your trading style. In this table, you can see the comparison between the trading styles allowed by SurgeTrader and Traders With Edge prop firms.
|Trading Styles||SurgeTrader||Traders With Edge|
Although most proprietary firms are more oriented to day trading, some allow holding positions overnight and even on weekends.
Here’s what is allowed by SurgeTrader and Traders With Edge.
|Trading Hours||SurgeTrader||Traders With Edge|
|Holding Over Weekend|
We all like to use the trading platform that we are used to. For this reason, prop firms support different trading platforms.
Here’s an extensive list of the platforms supported by SurgeTrader and Traders With Edge.
|Supported Platforms||SurgeTrader||Traders With Edge|
|Track N Trade|
The leverage provided by the prop firm may be an important factor when choosing it. This is especially true for day trading or scalping, where the position size is usually significantly bigger than for swing trading.
Here’s a comparison of the leverage provided by SurgeTrader and Traders With Edge prop firms.
|Leverage CFDs||SurgeTrader||Traders With Edge||Traders With Edge|
|Forex||1:10 (up to 1:20)||1:20, up to 1:40||1:50, up to 1:100|
|Indices||1:10||1:20, up to 1:40||1:50, up to 1:100|
|Metals||1:10 (up to 1:20)||1:20, up to 1:40||1:50, up to 1:100|
|Commodities||1:10||1:20, up to 1:40||1:50, up to 1:100|
|Stocks||1:5||1:20, up to 1:40||1:50, up to 1:100|
|Crypto||1:2||1:20, up to 1:40||1:50, up to 1:100|
|Leverage Futures||SurgeTrader||Traders With Edge||Traders With Edge|
Proprietary firms have several ways of payment.
Here’s a table with the comparison between the payment methods accepted by SurgeTrader and Traders With Edge.
|Payment Types||SurgeTrader||Traders With Edge|